A Supreme Court-directed investigation into 171 alleged fake police encounters in Assam has been thrown into uncertainty as the Assam Human Rights Commission (AHRC), the body tasked with conducting the probe, is struggling to function due to key vacancies at the top.
The Commission is currently without a chairman and one of its two members, raising concerns over whether the long-awaited inquiry can proceed and whether accountability for alleged human rights violations by law enforcement agencies will be ensured.
In May 2025, the Supreme Court directed the AHRC to carry out an independent and expeditious inquiry into 171 alleged fake encounters reported between May 2021 and August 2022. Following the order, the Commission’s full bench issued nearly 1,000 notices to police personnel attached to the teams involved in the incidents, as well as to the victims and their family members.
However, the inquiry has since hit a roadblock. AHRC chairman Justice (Retd.) Arup Goswami demitted office in July 2026, while commission member and advocate Santanu Barthakur completed his tenure in April 2026. The State Home Department has neither extended their terms nor appointed successors, leaving the Commission with only one member.
The vacancies have triggered concern among rights groups and legal observers. “An inquiry involving hundreds of police personnel and dozens of alleged encounter deaths cannot be allowed to languish because of administrative inaction,” a human rights activist said.
Official data indicate that between May 2021 and November 2026, Assam witnessed more than 190 police encounters involving persons already in custody. These incidents resulted in 42 deaths and 149 injuries. The figures are separate from the 171 cases being examined under the Supreme Court-mandated inquiry.
While the ongoing inquiry is confined to alleged fake encounters reported between May 2021 and August 2022, the larger tally reflects all incidents involving persons in police custody up to November 2026.
The latest custodial encounter death was reported on November 4, when Ghanakanta Gogoi, accused in the October 26 Guwahati hotel shooting that left five people dead, was shot dead in Sivasagar district. Police said he attempted to escape while being transported.
Law enforcement agencies have consistently maintained that the use of firearms in such incidents occurs in self-defence when detainees attack police personnel or attempt to flee.
For the families of those who died and for advocates seeking accountability, the uncertainty surrounding the Commission’s functioning has deepened concerns that justice may remain delayed unless the inquiry is allowed to proceed without further interruption.
